Fluoride in Drinking Water: A Question of Medical Ethics

The practice of adding fluoride to public drinking water has long been hailed as a triumph of public health, credited with reducing tooth decay in communities worldwide. Yet, this one-size-fits-all approach raises serious ethical questions that deserve scrutiny. While fluoride may benefit children’s developing teeth, its universal application to entire populations—regardless of age, health status, or individual needs—violates fundamental medical principles. By assuming everyone requires the same treatment, water fluoridation bypasses the doctor-patient relationship, ignores proper dosing, and risks harm to those who gain no benefit. This post explores why mass fluoridation is a flawed approach, using the analogy of adding aspirin to water to highlight its absurdity, and argues for a return to individualized care through physician-prescribed fluoride when necessary.